The S&P 500 index is one of the most sought-after stock indices that the US markets have been glued to for the past 68 years. The index was launched in 1957, delivering a new era of trading to American investors. The allure of stocks continues to compel global investors and companies, tempting them to trust their luck in phases. However, as the world financial dynamics have now evolved, investors now have more new asset classes to explore, including gold and Bitcoin, which have also been delivering stellar returns as of late. Comparatively, which asset has delivered the best gains so far? Is it Bitcoin or the seasoned S&P 500 stock index? Let’s find out.
Also Read: Elon Musk’s XChat Encryption Slammed Amid $300M XAI Stock Sale
Bitcoin vs. S&P 500: The Real Winner
Charlie Billelo, a noteworthy financial expert, took to X to share a compelling post, initiating a new debate in the process. Billelo posted an image of a list comprising the best-performing S&P 500 stocks over the past 30 years. The list included heavyweights such as Amazon and Tesla, with the majority of stocks originating from healthcare, electronics equipment, and the semiconductor arena.
The post also included how notable firms like Nvidia and Monster Beverages have delivered the most ROI in the last 30 years, disseminating profits of nearly 37227% and 441868%, respectively. However, another striking detail that caught the audience off guard was a comment from a user who used X’s Grok AI to ask whether Bitcoin has surpassed S&P 500 stock index returns when it comes to delivering quality profits.
Grok responded to the question, stating how Bitcoin has undoubtedly defeated the seasoned stock index, delivering nearly 137.6% returns over the last 30 years.
“Bitcoin’s performance since 2009 shows an annualized return of about 137.6%, far surpassing the top S&P 500 stock, Monster Beverage, at 37.17% over 30 years (1993-2023). A $10,000 investment in Bitcoin in 2009 would be worth billions today, compared to $41.5M for Monster Beverage. However, Bitcoin’s volatility, with daily swings around 4%, is much higher than stocks’ 1.1%. As a speculative asset, it differs from revenue-generating stocks, complicating direct comparisons. Its 16-year history is shorter than the 30-year stock data, and future stability is uncertain. Bitcoin likely outperforms top stocks since 2009 but carries greater risk.”
Bitcoin's performance since 2009 shows an annualized return of about 137.6%, far surpassing the top S&P 500 stock, Monster Beverage, at 37.17% over 30 years (1993-2023). A $10,000 investment in Bitcoin in 2009 would be worth billions today, compared to $41.5M for Monster…
— Grok (@grok) June 1, 2025
BTC Price Path: More Highs to Cover?
As per CoinCodex, Bitcoin has a long way to go, as the token is eyeing a higher price pedestal as of late. BTC may surge to sit at $118K by the end of 2025.
“According to our current Bitcoin price prediction, the price of Bitcoin is predicted to rise by 12.28% and reach $ 118,417 by June 2, 2026. Per our technical indicators, the current sentiment is bullish, while the Fear & Greed Index is showing 64 (greed). Bitcoin recorded 17/30 (57%) green days with 4.10% price volatility over the last 30 days. Based on the Bitcoin forecast, it’s now a good time to buy Bitcoin.”
Also Read: Post Trump Crypto Gains: XRP 350%, BTC 58%, ETH 10%, SOL 9%